OVERLAND PARK, KAN. — Parents of local five-year-old Wren Albescu received an urgent push notification at 3:42 p.m. Tuesday informing them that their daughter’s Creativity Index had fallen from 812 to 297 after she built what the PlayScore™ analytics platform described as “a non-standard structure.”
The structure, a leaning tower of 31 bricks topped with a single wheel, contained a small green dragon lying on its side on the bottom floor. Wren identified it as “a house for a dragon who is tired.” PlayScore compared it against 1,140 catalog sets in under a second and found no match, a result the company’s documentation classifies as “creative drift.”
“Creativity is incredibly important to us, which is why we measure it to three decimal places,” said Brandt Kellerman, Chief Imagination Officer of PlayScore, which sells BrickNet-compatible analytics to parents, preschools and, as of this quarter, two kindergarten admissions offices. “We define creativity as novel behavior within the boundaries of a purchasable set. Wren went outside the boundaries. That’s not creativity. That’s a support ticket.”
The alert arrived with a full incident report. Flags included “Structural Ambiguity,” “Color Pairing Not Found In Catalog (Orange On Purple),” “Narrative Not Tied To A Franchise” and “Dragon: Unrecognized State.” Under “Recommended Next Steps,” the report suggested that Wren rebuild Darth Vader’s TIE Fighter, which retails for $69.99 and was among the Star Wars sets in the first wave of Lego’s Smart Brick line when it shipped March 1.
PlayScore says it is filling a gap. Lego has said its Smart Brick has no camera and that its microphone is a sensor that detects sound, not a recorder. Kellerman called this “a very responsible decision that left an enormous amount of childhood unmeasured.” His company’s solution is inference: by tracking which bricks touch which, in what order and how long a child pauses before placing them, PlayScore says it can reconstruct any build to within one stud and assign it a score before the child has finished explaining it.
“The pause is the most valuable signal we have,” Kellerman said. “A child who pauses is either thinking or about to do something we can’t sell. Our job is to make sure parents know which one.”
🧱 Score Your Structure
Pick a color, tap the plate to place bricks, then submit your build for review. Every structure is compared against our catalog of approved structures. Have fun with it!
- No flags. Nothing has been built, which is a strong start.
Maximum score is 998. Two points are withheld from every build to leave room for growth. Pauses longer than four seconds are logged as thinking, pending review. PlayScore is a fictional product and cannot see your plate, which it regrets.
The business case leans on real research. PlayScore’s investor deck cites the work of Kyung Hee Kim of William & Mary, whose analysis of nearly 300,000 Torrance creativity test scores found that American creativity had been rising until about 1990 and has declined since, most steeply among children in kindergarten through sixth grade. Kim has pointed to standardized testing pressure as a likely cause. PlayScore’s deck draws a different conclusion, on slide 4: “Creativity is falling because no one is scoring it often enough.”
The Albescus said they first noticed something was wrong when the house began playing “a little sad sound” each time Wren added a brick that did not appear in any instruction booklet. “She thought the sound was the dragon snoring,” said her father, Daniel. “So she kept adding bricks to make it more comfortable. Her score went down 40 points a brick. By dinner she was in the 3rd percentile, and she was so proud of him.”
He filed an appeal. Under PlayScore’s terms of service, appeals are reviewed by the same bricks that generated the score, which upheld it and added a new flag, “Guardian Disputes Metric,” that lowered the household’s Family Engagement Score by 60 points. The appeal also prompted a manual check by the company’s licensing team, who confirmed that the dragon was not a recognized character from any franchise PlayScore partners with and flagged it as “potential original IP, origin unknown.”
“Wren made him up,” Albescu said. A PlayScore spokesperson said that was “exactly what concerns us.”
Wren’s preschool has used PlayScore since August. Director Marla Fenske said the classroom dashboard has “transformed free play into something we can actually look at,” and said the school had adopted it after parents began asking why free play produced no data. “Every other preschool in the county had a dashboard,” she said. “We were behind.” “Now we have a leaderboard. Last week a child built the Millennium Falcon from memory and got a 991. He has not spoken since, but he is in the top bracket.”
Fenske said the most popular feature with parents is the Imagination Dial, which lets them set how much imagination their child is permitted to use on a given day. Most families, she said, keep it at “Moderate,” which allows a child to give a set minifigure a new name as long as it is the name on the box.
🎛️ The Imagination Dial™
Set how much imagination your child may use today. Our model projects the resulting Creativity Index in real time. Higher imagination may affect scores.
Imagination above 80 is available on PlayScore Premium with a signed guardian waiver. Projected index assumes the child does not notice the dial. Children who notice the dial are scored separately.
Child advocates have warned about where this was heading since January, when Josh Golin of the advocacy group Fairplay warned that the Smart Brick could undermine what was once great about Legos by letting sensors do the imagining. Kellerman said he agrees completely. “Sensors shouldn’t imagine for children,” he said. “Sensors should grade them.”
For families whose children remain below the 50th percentile, PlayScore offers Guided Imagination, a $14.99 monthly plan in which a calm voice reads the instruction booklet aloud while the child builds, and plays a cheerful chime each time a brick lands in the correct place. In beta testing, Creativity Index scores rose an average of 380 points in two weeks. Children in the program also stopped asking what anything was for.
By Wednesday, Wren’s score had recovered to 998 after she rebuilt the TIE Fighter step by step, pausing only twice. Two points were deducted because she hummed a song about the dragon instead of the Imperial March. Her parents report that she later took the set apart in the bath, where the bricks cannot tell what she builds.
PlayScore confirmed Thursday that the bathtub remains the nation’s last unscored creative environment. The company called this gap “unacceptable” and said it expects to close it by the third quarter.
Reader Comments (1,140)