SAN CLEMENTE, Calif. — Showing a composure that political observers said has been missing from American concessions for some time, San Clemente's wildfire goats formally conceded the Measure M race on Wednesday in a brief hillside ceremony, then ate a "Yes on M" yard sign, most of its wire stake and a printout of the results.
The herd, which numbers about 100 and has worked the brush above town since a pilot program began in March 2025, had more riding on the measure than anyone and no way to vote on it. Measure M would have raised the city's sales tax by one cent for 10 years, bringing in about $15 million a year, with half going to the beaches and half to wildfire prevention, goats included. About 64% of voters said no. The Pacific Ocean, which opposed the beach half by eating it, declared victory last week.
The concession came at 7:40 a.m. from Gristle, a 140-pound Boer who serves as the herd's informal spokesgoat, standing on a boulder above a fuel break. It consisted of a single bleat, about four seconds long, which the herd's contractor translated for reporters.
"The people have spoken," said Ruth Abernathy-Cole, 61, owner of Hillside Appetite Grazing LLC, reading from a notecard Gristle had already started on. "And what they have said is brush."
Gristle then turned to a "Yes on M" sign that had stood at the edge of the fuel break since September and ate it in about 11 minutes, starting with the Y. Witnesses called the process unhurried and free of bitterness. "He didn't kick it. He didn't blame the sign," said a city maintenance worker who watched from a utility truck. "I've seen grown men take a loss worse than that, and they didn't even get to eat anything."
Political scientists said the goats had set a new standard. "In one morning they accepted the result, thanked the voters and consumed the evidence," said Dr. Nadine Brightwater, a senior fellow at the Institute for Things Everyone Agrees Someone Should Fund. "That is the whole grieving process. Most candidates get stuck at denial. The goats went straight to digestion."
The herd ran on a record anyone could see from the freeway: bare slopes where there had been dry brush, at a fraction of the cost of human crews. Laguna Beach, a few miles up the coast, says goat grazing typically costs 10% or less per acre compared with hand crews. The herd also grew its own workforce. About 25 kids have been born on the job since the pilot began, which makes the goats the only municipal program in Orange County that expands without a vote.
Outreach was harder. Volunteers who left door hangers along the hillside reported that the door hangers were eaten. A "Goats for M" rally at a trailhead last month drew about 120 attendees, roughly 100 of them goats, and broke up during the second speech, when the rally's banner was consumed. The goats raised no money and spent none, though supporters made in-kind contributions of ivy, mustard and, in one case, a wreath.
The Yard Sign Buffet
A gracious loss takes time and fiber. Choose what the spokesgoat processes next. The interpreter will read his statement.
Gristle, the interpreter and the menu are invented. Goats do eat almost anything, and HuckFinn does not recommend feeding them plastic. Brush may be eaten as often as you like. It will not be funded either way.
Opponents said the vote was never about the goats. Their argument, made on lawn signs the goats later ate, was that fighting nature is an expensive hobby for a small city. The goats did not dispute this. They have long described themselves as nature's cheaper subcontractor.
Voters outside a taco stand on El Camino Real said they had nothing against the herd. "I love the goats. I'm a goat person, emotionally," said Doug Halvorsen, 58, interviewed at the same taco stand after the ocean's win. "But groceries are up, gas is up, and now I'm being asked to pay for goats. I was raised to believe brush is the one thing a hillside comes with." He said he had voted against the sand for the same reason, "which I keep hearing is the problem."
Sacramento has not been kind to the herd either. A state rule that let grazing companies pay goat herders a monthly wage instead of standard overtime expired July 1 after an effort to extend it stalled in the Legislature, and operators have warned it could put some of them out of business. In a single year the goats lost a labor law and an election, and they have taken both the same way. "They are the only workforce in California whose pay is also the job," Brightwater said. "You can't cut their wages without cutting the work. Voters found a way."
The city has not given up. The council previously set aside $100,000 to keep the pilot going, and staff are studying what a permanent citywide program would cost. Asked what the herd would do in the meantime, Abernathy-Cole said the goats would keep clearing brush every day, funded or not. "They don't really understand money," she said. "To be fair, neither did the ballot."
The Brush Bid Desk
Choose how many acres of hillside to clear. Four bidders have responded. One of them is the ocean.
Per-acre rates are rough Southern California figures reported elsewhere, not San Clemente's contract prices: about $1,300 an acre for goats, a grazing contractor's average, and up to about $4,000 for hand clearing on hard terrain, from Los Angeles. The $100,000 set aside for the pilot and the share of the vote are real. The ocean's bid is real in spirit.
By Wednesday afternoon the herd had cleared the slope of campaign signage, without regard to party. Observers noted that the goats ate the "No on M" signs too and appeared to enjoy them more, which Abernathy-Cole asked reporters not to read as a policy position. "It is a texture position," she said. The program's sheep, which do whatever the goats do, ate whatever the goats ate, and pollsters now consider them the herd's only reliable swing bloc. The donkey, which guards the herd, declined to comment, as he has throughout the campaign, making him the only participant in the 2026 election who said nothing he would have to take back.
There is already talk of 2028. Supporters say a new citizen initiative would need signatures, and that gathering them near the herd is "logistically a problem," because the herd eats petitions. Gristle has been seen looking at the clipboards.
At press time, the goats had moved to a hillside above the beach, where they were clearing brush for free, the only campaign promise of the 2026 cycle that anyone kept. Below them, the Pacific was taking the beach, also for free. Officials said both were working well within budget.
Reader Comments (1,064)